Alternative

Moda vs Judgment Labs

For AI agents in production, Moda checks every trace with no judge to write, and ranks problems by the users they reach.

Judgment Labs makes Judgment, a hosted platform that traces agents, finds recurring failures it calls Issues, labels traces with judges you define, and runs test suites that can gate pull requests in CI. Its judgeval SDKs are open source under Apache-2.0, its pricing is public with a free plan, and it announced $32 million in funding led by Greenoaks and Lightspeed in May 2026.

Moda at a glance

  • Every trace

    checked by built-in detections for frustration, tool failures, laziness, and hallucinations, with no judge to write and no sampling rate to set.

    How it works
  • Users affected

    ranks every problem, so the failure that reaches the most people comes first, with the traces behind it.

    How it works
  • SOC 2 and HIPAA

    SOC 2 Type I, SOC 2 Type II, and HIPAA compliance, with self-hosted deployment available.

For teams running agents in production

  • Cardboard
  • Octolane
  • Boardy
  • Pax Historia
  • Maywood
  • Final Round AI
  • Kanu
  • Brief
  • CoreLayer
  • Autumn
  • Codewisp

Replay

Replay production conversations with simulated tools. No mocks to write.

Replay a prompt or model change against the traces that failed, before it ships. Moda turns those production traces into eval cases, plays each one under your current configuration and under the change, and scores both.

  • Your production traces are the test cases

    Each case comes from a real trace. A simulated user plays the scenario your user played, turn after turn, so the agent faces the conversation that actually went wrong, not one input someone copied into a test.

  • Tool calls are simulated for you

    When the replayed agent calls a tool, Moda simulates the tool from the calls recorded in your production traces: the answer comes back in the recorded output format, and fails the way the real tool fails. You write no mocks and no fixtures, and no real tool is called.

  • Both sides judged on every case

    A judge scores every case under Production and under Proposed. The results show the pass rates side by side, and each case opens the full replayed transcript, tool calls included, so you can check a verdict against what the agent did.

In Judgment, a test run starts from your code: each case's input is sent to your agent, and your judges score the trace it produces. A case replays one input, so any tool your agent calls runs for real or behind a mock your team maintains. Scoring stored traces instead re-grades past runs without running the agent.

One replay, step by step
  1. 1Build an eval set from the production traces that failed
  2. 2A simulated user replays each conversation with your agent
  3. 3Every tool call is simulated from the tool calls recorded in your traces
  4. 4A judge scores Production and Proposed, case by case

Where Judgment Labs wins

When Judgment Labs is the better choice

You want to start today, on your own

Judgment publishes its pricing and has a free Beginner plan with $100 in credits the first month and $50 a month after; Pro is $250 a month. Moda access is invite-only and pricing is custom.

You want evals run from your own CI

Judgment test suites are started from your own code: they run your agent on each case, score the traces with your judges, and can fail a CI build when a case fails. Moda replays changes in the dashboard and can post an evals check on your pull requests.

You want to write your own judges in code

Code judges run Python you upload, Condition judges check cost, latency, and errors deterministically, and you can align a judge by marking its labels Agree or Disagree. Moda's custom signals are written in plain language.

You want open-source SDKs

The judgeval SDKs for Python and TypeScript are Apache-2.0. Moda is not open source.

You want it in your own cloud account

Judgment's Enterprise plan runs inside your own AWS or GCP account. Moda offers self-hosted deployment on request.

You need broader framework coverage

Judgment documents integrations for LangGraph and LangChain, the OpenAI Agents SDK, Google ADK, Pipecat, LiveKit Agents, and Pydantic AI, and maps OpenInference attributes. Moda has Python and Node SDKs, the Vercel AI SDK and Claude Agent SDK, and OpenTelemetry with GenAI, OpenLLMetry, and Vercel AI SDK attributes.

Difference 1

Moda checks every trace out of the box. Judgment's judges label the traffic you turn on and sample.

What Moda does

Moda reads every production trace end to end and detects the failures that never throw an error: frustrated users, failing tools, lazy answers, and hallucinations. Add your own checks in plain language and get alerts in Slack, Linear, or email.

The detections are built for agent failures. A hallucination is a claim the agent's recorded tool results contradict, and laziness is an agent that falls short of the effort the task needed. There is no judge to write, no rubric to align, and no sampling rate to choose, and detections typically appear within minutes of ingest.

How Judgment Labs approaches it

Judgment's judges are yours to define. An Agent judge follows a rubric you describe in plain words, a Condition judge checks a trace's duration, cost, errors, or span names, and a Code judge runs Python you upload. During setup, Judgment starts an Issues run on your first traces and creates up to five judges from what it finds.

A judge labels live traffic only after you turn on online monitoring. Its sampling rate is the share of incoming traces it evaluates, from 0 to 100%, and the docs suggest lowering it to control cost on high-volume projects. Judge runs use Judgment Units.

The same job in Judgment Labs and in Moda

In Judgment Labs

  1. 1Describe a judge's rubric, or upload Python for a Code judge
  2. 2Turn on online monitoring and set a sampling rate
  3. 3Each judge run uses Judgment Units

In Moda

  • Built-in detections run on every trace
  • Built for agent failures, hallucinations included
  • No judge to write, no sampling rate to set

Difference 2

Moda ranks problems by users affected. Judgment's Issues inbox sorts by severity.

What Moda does

Failures are grouped into problems ranked by how many users they affect. Each problem shows the traces behind it, the turn where it went wrong, and related problems that share the cause.

New traces are attributed to existing problems within minutes, and a problem you marked fixed reopens if the failure comes back. Problems can be filed in Linear, where status syncs both ways.

How Judgment Labs approaches it

Issues detection is an agent run that happens on a schedule or when you ask for it. Each run reads your recent traces, looks for errors, tool failures, latency and cost outliers, negative judge labels, and failures that show up only in what the agent said or did, and groups them by root cause. Turning it on asks for custom instructions on what to look for.

Every Issue has a severity (Critical, High, Medium, or Low) that you can change, a trend such as First seen or Regressed, an Impact note on who it affects, and evidence traces. The inbox sorts by severity by default, or by latest or evidence, and Fix with hands an Issue to a coding agent.

The same job in Judgment Labs and in Moda

In Judgment Labs

  1. 1Write custom instructions for Issues detection
  2. 2An agent run reads recent traces on a schedule
  3. 3The inbox sorts Issues by severity

In Moda

  • Failures are grouped into problems as traces arrive
  • Problems are ranked by users affected
  • A fixed problem reopens if the failure returns

Side by side

Capability by capability

The same rows appear on every Moda comparison page, including the ones where Judgment Labs is ahead.

Moda vs Judgment Labs, capability by capability
CapabilityModaJudgment LabsWhy it matters
Setup effortSDKs or OpenTelemetry: moda init has your coding agent add an SDK, or point an existing OpenTelemetry exporter at Moda. The built-in detections run on traces as they arrive.SDKs or OTLP for traces. Setup hands tracing to your coding agent, starts an Issues run on your first traces, and creates up to five judges; Issues detection asks for custom instructions.Time to the first useful answer about your agent, not just the first stored trace.
Failure detectionBuilt-in signals on every trace: user emotion and frustration, tool failures, laziness, and hallucinations (replies the trace shows are false). Custom signals in plain language.Judges you define, as an Agent rubric, deterministic conditions, or Python code, run on live traffic once online monitoring is on, at a sampling rate from 0 to 100%.Whether failures that never throw an error are caught on the traces nobody reads, and how much setup that takes.
Grouping and ranking failuresFailures grouped into problems ranked by how many users they affect, with the traces behind each one.Issues: a scheduled or on-demand agent run groups failures in recent traces by root cause, each with a severity and trend; the inbox sorts by severity.Decides what your team works on first.
Testing a change before it shipsReplay a prompt or model change against traces from production and compare pass rates with the current configuration. Tool calls are simulated from the tool calls recorded in those traces, so there are no mocks to write.Test suites send each case's input to your agent and score the trace it produces with your judges. Stored traces can be re-scored without running the agent.Shows whether a change helps on the cases that actually failed before users see it.
Offline evals and CIReplays of a change against traces from production, run and reviewed in the dashboard. Moda can also post an evals check on your pull requests: each push runs the eval sets you choose and reports pass or fail, with a link to the run.Versioned test suites of cases with expected judge labels, started from your code, that can fail a CI build when a case fails.Matters most when your release process gates on eval scores in CI.
Alert destinationsSlack, Linear, and email.Judge actions send email or post to Slack when a judge returns a given label.Alerts should land where your team already triages work.
SDKs and frameworksPython and Node SDKs; Vercel AI SDK and Claude Agent SDK; any OpenTelemetry source; HTTP API.judgeval SDKs for Python and TypeScript; integrations for model clients, LangGraph, the OpenAI Agents SDK, Claude Agent SDK, Vercel AI SDK, Google ADK, and others, plus OTLP from any language.Less glue code for the languages and frameworks you already run.
OpenTelemetryOTLP/HTTP trace endpoint (JSON or protobuf). Reads OpenTelemetry GenAI, OpenLLMetry, and Vercel AI SDK attributes, and groups spans across OpenTelemetry traces by moda.conversation_id or gen_ai.conversation.id.OTLP/HTTP at api.judgmentlabs.ai/otel/v1/traces. Maps GenAI, OpenInference, LangSmith, Vercel AI SDK, and Logfire attributes, and can run as one more span processor next to another tool.One instrumentation can feed more than one tool, so trying a second one costs a config change.
Prompt managementPrompt files versioned from your repository, with release labels and per-version attribution of production calls. Not in the request path: the SDKs do not fetch prompts.Deprecated, with the CLI, in October 2026.Decides whether prompts ship with your code or are served to your app at runtime.
Open source and self-hostingSelf-hosted deployment available; contact the team to set it up. Not open source.The judgeval SDKs are Apache-2.0; the platform is not open source. Enterprise can run Judgment in your own AWS or GCP account.Often required when trace data cannot leave your own infrastructure.
Security and complianceSOC 2 Type I, SOC 2 Type II, and HIPAA compliance.SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA compliant, with SSO and RBAC. Traces are not used to train models.Often a procurement gate before any trial starts.
Pricing and free tierInvite-only, with custom pricing. Request access to get a workspace.Public pricing. Free Beginner plan with monthly credits and 14-day retention; Pro at $250 a month; Enterprise custom.Decides whether you can start today without talking to anyone.

Try it

Try Moda on the same traces

Judgment and Moda both take OpenTelemetry traces over OTLP/HTTP, so the fairest test is your own traffic in both. If your agent exports through an OpenTelemetry Collector, add a Moda exporter next to Judgment's; Judgment keeps receiving everything it does today. Moda ingest accepts uncompressed request bodies only, so the Moda exporter sets compression: none.

Moda reads OpenTelemetry GenAI, OpenLLMetry, and Vercel AI SDK attributes. It groups spans into one trace by moda.conversation_id, or gen_ai.conversation.id, across OpenTelemetry traces, and attributes them to a user by moda.user_id; set both on every span of a multi-turn agent. Spans that carry their content only in judgment.* or OpenInference attributes need GenAI attributes or the Moda SDK for Python or Node.js.

otel-collector-config.yaml
receivers:
  otlp:
    protocols:
      grpc: {}
      http: {}

processors:
  batch: {}

exporters:
  # Your existing Judgment exporter, unchanged.
  otlphttp/judgment:
    traces_endpoint: https://api.judgmentlabs.ai/otel/v1/traces
    headers:
      Authorization: Bearer ${env:JUDGMENT_API_KEY}
      X-Project-Id: ${env:JUDGMENT_PROJECT_ID}
  otlphttp/moda:
    traces_endpoint: https://moda-ingest.modas.workers.dev/v1/traces
    headers:
      Authorization: Bearer ${env:MODA_API_KEY}
    # Moda ingest rejects compressed request bodies; the Collector gzips by default.
    compression: none

service:
  pipelines:
    traces:
      receivers: [otlp]
      processors: [batch]
      exporters: [otlphttp/judgment, otlphttp/moda]

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Judgment Labs vs Moda: what is the difference?

Judgment Labs (sometimes spelled Judgement Labs) and Moda both find recurring agent failures in production. Moda's detections for frustration, tool failures, laziness, and hallucinations run on every trace with nothing to set up, and problems are ranked by how many users they affect. In Judgment, you define judges and choose a sampling rate for each, and Issues are found by a scheduled agent run and sorted by severity. Judgment leads on self-serve pricing, test suites you run from your own CI, code-based judges, and open-source SDKs.

Does Judgment Labs check every trace?

Its judges label live traffic once you turn on online monitoring, at a sampling rate you set from 0 to 100%, and Issues detection reads recent traces on a schedule or when you ask. Moda's built-in detections run on every trace without that setup.

How is replay in Moda different from Judgment test suites?

A Judgment test suite sends each case's input to your agent and scores the trace it produces, so any tool the agent calls runs for real or behind a mock you maintain. In Moda you replay a prompt or model change against traces from production: a simulated user plays each conversation, every tool call is simulated from the tool calls recorded in your traces, and a judge compares pass rates with the current configuration. Judgment's suites run from your own CI; Moda's replays run in the dashboard, and Moda can also post an evals check on your pull requests.

Can I run Moda and Judgment Labs at the same time?

Yes. Both accept OpenTelemetry traces over OTLP/HTTP, so an OpenTelemetry Collector can send the same spans to each. Add a Moda exporter with compression: none next to your Judgment exporter, and set moda.conversation_id and moda.user_id on your spans.

What does Moda cost?

Moda access is invite-only and pricing is custom. Request access at moda.dev/signup, or email founders@modaflows.com for a quote. Judgment Labs publishes its pricing and has a free plan.

Can I self-host Moda, or is it open source?

Moda offers self-hosted deployment; contact the team at moda.dev/contact to set it up. Moda is not open source. Judgment's judgeval SDKs are Apache-2.0, and its Enterprise plan can run inside your own AWS or GCP account.

What security compliance does Moda have?

SOC 2 Type I, SOC 2 Type II, and HIPAA. Judgment Labs is SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA compliant.

Try Moda

Infrastructure for catching AI agent mistakes in production and turning them into evals.